Seaworthy Insurance reviews
Seaworthy Insurance is an independent disability insurance brokerage for physicians, dentists, CRNAs, attorneys, and tech professionals. Clients rate the firm 5.0 stars across 76 Google reviews (November 2026), and it is BBB Accredited with an A+ rating.
What clients say about Seaworthy Insurance
"Phenomenal experience working with the team. After a year or two with my insurance, they helped me negotiate a different rate and then handled the billing issues for me since we were halfway through a cycle. Would recommend, 10/10."
"Phil went above and beyond to help us. He was diligent, engaged, and thorough. He has been helping us for years and is dedicated and reliable. Highly recommend!"
"Phil is the best! He's helped me get the best possible coverage from the insurance companies when other agents came back with tons of exclusions."
"I highly recommend Phil and his team when looking for disability insurance. He is very knowledgeable and made the process straightforward. He and his team were quick to respond to any questions I had during the application process."
"I had a wonderful experience working with Phil. He was incredibly knowledgeable, patient, and responsive throughout the entire process of setting up my disability and life insurance. He took the time to explain all of my options, answered every question thoroughly, and made what could have been an overwhelming process feel straightforward and stress-free."
"Phil and his crew have been very helpful in getting me set up with all my life and disability insurance needs. Phil and Jack reached out to me personally with any suggestions. I believe they have had my best interest at heart through the process. Overall, good communicators and good advice."
"I have had the pleasure of working with Phil N. for many years to obtain professional disability insurance. He is incredibly knowledgeable, prompt, and friendly. I would recommend any of my colleagues to him and to Seaworthy Insurance!"
"Phil has been my broker for years and I make several referrals to him. He has kept our family well prepared."
"Phil was recommended to me by an advisor and I could not be more pleased with the experience. He handled updating my life and disability insurance with ease. The process was seamless and quick."
"Phil was the best! So patient, so knowledgeable. He walked me through it all and answered all of my questions. If anyone needs disability insurance I would recommend him without reservations!"
"Phil has been incredibly helpful through multiple adjustments to my disability insurance as my career and stage of life has evolved! He is very responsive and easy to work with! Highly recommend."
"So helpful and willing to answer any question I have. Truly made the process so easy."
"I took disability insurance from Phil. Very helpful. Highly recommend him."
"Phil Neujahr and Chawna Dill has been extremely helpful and responsive to my questions. I enjoyed their initial intake process, which was all-online, so I could fill in my situation without pressure. Phil has been professional, helpful, and non-pushy, always striving to ensure I have all the information I need to make the decision suited for me. He is open and upfront on potential issues regarding my specific situation or lifestyle choices, but is never pushy."
"I've been working with Phil for my disability insurance since 2020, and I couldn't recommend him more highly. He is remarkably patient, takes the time to clearly explain every detail, and never rushes key decisions. His communication and long-term support have been exceptional from day one through today. If you need a reliable, knowledgeable, and dedicated insurance broker, Phil is the best in the business!"
"Phil and his team were great. They walked me through every step of the process to increase my disability insurance. They communicated and advocated for the best rate and coverage for my circumstances. I will be referring my colleagues."
"Phil and his team were exceptional! They made getting disability and life insurance coverage as easy as possible. Very accessible and responsive. I would recommend him to anyone looking for insurance."
"Seaworthy is by far the easiest insurance group I've ever worked with. I've use them personally and referred others to them. Everyone is very knowledgable and super easy to communicate with."
"Had a great experince with Phil. With initial insurance application he was extremely helpful and found me the best price quickly and helped me understand the details of all of the policies I was considering. When there was an initial exclusion placed on my policy due to findings from my health records, Phil helped me understand what that meant, and how to remove it. Two years later he followed up and the result was the removal of my exclusion. I had a great experience, and would highly recommend his services to everyone interested"
"I had a great experience with Phil obtaining my disability insurance. It was easy to work with him and his team was very efficient and timely in all interactions and support. Strongly recommend!"
"Been working with Phil for a few years now for disability and life coverage. He goes above and beyond what is asked - very transparent, honest, knowledgeable, empathetic, and communicative. He was able to navigate my somewhat complicated situation and get me the best deal possible. I always felt like I knew what step we were on in the process, and he laid out my options plainly in a manner that was easy to understand. This is the group you go to when you feel like you don’t have options!"
"Phil and his team went above and beyond to answer all my questions and help me find the best insurance plan for me! He was patient, knowledgable, and trustworthy. Would definitely recommend!"
"Phil has been great to work with. He made the process of obtaining coverage and adjusting as needed very simple."
"I have been working with Phil for the last 10 years for my different insurance need, Him and his Team are professional and very easy going Highly recommended!"
"Very patient and thorough. Explained things in a way I could understand."
"Phil was very patient and very helpful. Highly recommend him and his team!"
"Phil and his team are absolutely the best! Very responsive and reliable. I would definitely use them again."
"Phil was great helping me with getting the ball rolling on disability insurance."
"We had an incredible experience working with Phil and his team to establish disability insurance for my husband. They were incredibly informative, patient, and kind throughout the entire process. They took the time to answer all of our questions, and made what could have felt overwhelming so much easier and more manageable. We truly appreciated how professional, responsive, and supportive the team was from start to finish. Highly recommend working with Phil and his team!"
"Phil was great and knowledgable, highly recommend him!"
"Phil was great! Very professional, helpful, and reliable. Would definitely recommend."
"Jack Howard was very helpful in getting my disability and life insurance benefits increased to fit my needs! Highly recommend!"
"Phil is an honest, knowledgeable professional. He goes the extra mile to cover his clients with quality policies. I am very appreciative!"
"Phil was so helpful and knowledgeable throughout this process! Highly recommend"
"Seaworthy and Phil were great to work with! They are knowledgeable about professionals coming from the tech industry which was very reassuring."
Where do these reviews come from?
Every review on this page was written by a client on the firm's Google Business Profile. The wording is the client's own, with light punctuation cleanup only. The page shows a selection of the reviews that include a written comment, and the complete, current list is on Google. The occupation under each name comes from the firm's client records, and a card reads "Google review" where it has not been confirmed.
Is this the same firm as Physician's Disability Insurance Agency?
Yes. Seaworthy Insurance was founded in 2011 as Physician's Disability Insurance Agency and took the Seaworthy Insurance name in June 2026. The firm, its partners, and its license are the same, so reviews written before the rename are reviews of this firm.
Is this the Seaworthy Insurance that insured boats?
No. Seaworthy Insurance Company was a marine insurer that GEICO renamed GEICO Marine Insurance Company in 2015. Older reviews and forum posts about boat or marine policies under the Seaworthy name are about that company. Seaworthy Insurance, the disability insurance brokerage, is unrelated to it, does not sell boat or marine coverage, and adopted the Seaworthy name in June 2026.
How else can you check the firm?
Seaworthy Insurance is BBB Accredited with an A+ rating. Its agency and producer licenses are listed on the licenses page, including California license #0H52962. The partners' professional designations are listed on their team pages, with a link to the credential record or certificate for each.
Ready to compare your options?
Request a free quote comparison. We'll review your situation and show you what the top carriers are offering for your profession.
